What Rainforest?

Sarawak opposition: Dams unnecessary
August 6, 2008, 4:55 pm
Filed under: Dams, Media Reports

Malaysiakini.com, 6 August 2008

by Tony Thien

Sarawak PKR chief Dominique Ng has come out lambasting the proposed building of 12 hydro dams in the state.

The dam projects – announced by state-owned public-listed Sarawak Energy Berhad (SEB) – will only endanger the environment, he said, adding that Sarawak had electricity self-sufficiency. 

However the state claimed that the combined total of 7,000 MW from the 12 proposed dams was necessary for large energy intensive industries like aluminium smelter plants and for export – primarily to Peninsular Malaysia.

In a statement, Ng – the party’s sole elected assemblyperson – questioned both the independence and validity of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the projects and it effectiveness in influencing policy decisions.

“It is apparent that the EIA is in fact a piece of useless trash, self-fabricated to justify the 12 very large dams, but lacking any persuasiveness whatsoever,” he added.

Ng was commenting on last week’s statement by the Sarawak Environment and Public Health Minister Michael Manyin that decisions to build the 12 dams were to be based on mandatory EIAs following existing legislation.

State government must be transparent

He alluded to repeated opinions of environmental NGOs condemning the falsified information contained in government-sponsored EIAs which blatantly served as the tools to legitimise the construction of large dams.

Ng asked the government to be transparent and release all EIAs related to the dams, saying that the public must be allowed to evaluate the depth and comprehensiveness of the documents based on universally accepted parameters – factoring in the safety of human populations.

The Bakun dam project flooded primal tropical forest the size of Singapore and set a dangerous precedent. Bakun alone was enough to supply East Malaysia’s electricity needs, Ng explained.

“The 12 dams like Bakun will similarly be extravagant and unnecessary in the scale of electricity generation, wanton in environmental and biodiversity destruction, violent in the dispossession and displacement of ethnic groups, and unpredictable in future environmental calamity and payback,” the Padungan representative said.

Last Thursday the state cabinet in a meeting chaired by Chief Minister Abdul Taib Mahmud approved the construction of the RM3 billion 940MW Murum Dam above Bakun dam, with the project awarded to a Chinese state-owned investment company China Three Gorges Project Corporation, builder of the world’s largest dam.


1 Comment so far
Leave a comment

Three Gorges Project Corporation … hmmn … according to Wikipedia, the state Environmental Protection Administration of China equivalent to NREB in Sarawak and DOE in the peninsula) had used the Environmental Impact Assessment process to halt 30 projects in 2004. And guess what? Among the 30 questionable projects rejected either in terms of poor planning or huge negative impact to the environment or both included 3 hydro-power plants proposed by the Three Gorges Project Company.

Not surprisingly, the power plant projects were subsequently approved.

Given the Malaysia ‘kurang boleh’ construction records, (a case in point is the MRR2 pillar), it’s no exaggeration to think poorly of these dam construction projects. What we may have is a deadly combination of Malaysia corruption-ridden construction project + China questionable expertise.

Comment by hornbill

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: